ScottMadden»Insights Library»White Paper»Revisiting the Duck Curve: An Exploration of Its Existence, Impact, and Migration Potential

Revisiting the Duck Curve: An Exploration of Its Existence, Impact, and Migration Potential

Download PDF

May we suggest:

Integrating Smart Utility-Scale Solar

Smart utility-scale solar could become a reality with the convergence of three important market requirements, which we call the “solar trifecta.” Learn about the three pillars in this new article, featured by the Georgia Tech Strategic Energy Institute.

Making Sense Of Solar: New Methods To Assess Penetration And Oversupply Risks

This article, featured in the July 2017 Solar Industry Magazine, builds from the dynamic relationships between three operating variables in an electric system to derive new metrics that estimate the impacts and risks of solar in major U.S. electricity markets as of the end of 2015, the most recent year of data available.

Proactive Solutions to Curtailment Risk: Identifying New Contract Structures for Utility-Scale Renewables

SEPA and ScottMadden review a set of alternative curtailment approaches for Hawaii to consider and deploy that better manage curtailment risk and should result in more equitable power purchase agreements over the long term.

The Energy Industry Update – Volume 18, Issue 1

Themed “Recalibration,” this Update examines some of the emerging and continuing trends in the industry, with the hope that it will help energy executives “recalibrate” as our industry anticipates, and creates, the next “new normal.”

Print

Share

In 2013, the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) conducted an analysis to understand how increasing penetrations of renewable resources would impact grid conditions. The result was the iconic “duck curve” chart, which predicted that as variable generation grows so too will the trough of load served by conventional supply in midday. ScottMadden analyzes if actual results align with the original forecast in the new report: Revisiting the Duck Curve: An Exploration of Its Existence, Impact, and Migration Potential.

ScottMadden finds the duck curve is real and growing faster than expected. In addition, the analysis reveals some interesting, unexpected, and important nuances. In particular, the duck curve is:

Producing net loads lower than forecast
Increasing ramps throughout the year
Most severe on the weekends
Occurring in multiple seasons, not just spring months
Driven by utility-scale solar in California, not distributed resources

“One of the most important implications is the duck curve may migrate to other parts of the U.S.,” said Greg Litra, partner and energy, clean tech, and sustainability research lead. “Growing numbers of utility-scale solar installations could mean that ‘the duck’ could migrate to states like Arizona, Georgia, Nevada, North Carolina, and Texas in the not-too-distant future.”

Overall, understanding the root cause and comprehensive impact of the duck curve is essential before developing strategies to address operational impacts. Solutions for a seasonal, weekend, utility-scale solar issue may well be different than solutions for an every day, distributed resource issue.

Additional Contributing Author: Paul Quinlan

Contributing Authors

Chris Vlahoplus Partner and Clean Tech & Sustainability Practice Leader

Greg Litra Partner

May we suggest:

Integrating Smart Utility-Scale Solar

Smart utility-scale solar could become a reality with the convergence of three important market requirements, which we call the “solar trifecta.” Learn about the three pillars in this new article, featured by the Georgia Tech Strategic Energy Institute.

Making Sense Of Solar: New Methods To Assess Penetration And Oversupply Risks

This article, featured in the July 2017 Solar Industry Magazine, builds from the dynamic relationships between three operating variables in an electric system to derive new metrics that estimate the impacts and risks of solar in major U.S. electricity markets as of the end of 2015, the most recent year of data available.

Proactive Solutions to Curtailment Risk: Identifying New Contract Structures for Utility-Scale Renewables

SEPA and ScottMadden review a set of alternative curtailment approaches for Hawaii to consider and deploy that better manage curtailment risk and should result in more equitable power purchase agreements over the long term.

The Energy Industry Update – Volume 18, Issue 1

Themed “Recalibration,” this Update examines some of the emerging and continuing trends in the industry, with the hope that it will help energy executives “recalibrate” as our industry anticipates, and creates, the next “new normal.”

Clean Tech &
Sustainability

We work step-by-step with clients to ensure each project’s success. Our strong team of consultants employs an adaptable framework to guide clients to the best decision for their unique situations. We do what we say we are going to do, with integrity, tenacity, and a genuine passion for the work throughout the entire project.

Learn more about our Clean Tech & Sustainability practice area.

Let's get the conversation started.
404.814.0020
info@scottmadden.com

Or let us get in touch with you: Contact Form

Revisiting the Duck Curve: An Exploration of Its Existence, Impact, and Migration Potential

Welcome to ScottMadden!